While they are not a hard science, and should be viewed with as much scepticism as (video) gamers would look at a site like Metacritic, it cannot be denied that the user ratings on BoardGameGeek play a huge part in helping people choose which board games to buy, play and/or argue about.
Crush Marvel Snap ‘Zoo Decks’ With Killmonger
Share SubtitlesOffEnglishShare this VideoFacebookTwitterEmailRedditLinkview videoKillmonger Is One Of Marvel Snap‘s Best Cards
The site, a priceless asset that is everything from a community forum to a wiki to an assets platform, allows anyone who has played a game to give it a rating. The more people who rate a game, the more valuable that rating becomes, and while it’s far from a perfect system—this 2019 post has a very good guide to the ratings’ pros and cons—most people, myself included, can’t help but look at a game’s rating and feel that it has some kind of impact.
You’d think that, with the site being over 20 years old, there would have been dozens, or even hundreds of games that have risen to occupy top spot on BGG’s ratings chart. But no! In the site’s existence—or more accurately in the time that the ratings system has been in place—only eight games have ever clawed their way to the top of the pile.
The first seven are:
Paths of GloryTigris and EuphratesPuerto RicoAgricolaTwilight StrugglePandemic Legacy Season 1Gloomhaven
Gloomhaven, the biggest board game of the past decade, had been #1 since December 2017, but this month was finally dethroned, bringing its five-year reign to an end. And not by a new game, either; it was instead overhauled by Brass: Birmingham, a game first released in 2018. While I’ve never got around to reviewing the game on the site, I did play it for a bit back in 2019 and thought it was pretty good! Not best of all time good, but then, that’s why review aggregations are a tricky business.
In lieu of a Kotaku write-up, then, here’s SUSD’s review of Brass: Birmingham instead, in case you’re wondering what kind of game can find itself collectively rated so highly among board game nerds:
In case you’re wondering what game might next achieve this feat, BGG say that the point differential between Gloomhaven and Brass: Birmingham is so minute that they “will likely swap spots for a while”, as will Pandemic Legacy (which is also right up there), so fresh blood might have to wait a while.
BGG’s post announcing the shift also includes some very useful advice for review aggregation, regardless of the medium:
Here’s the top 10 as it stands today, if you’re interested in seeing the full list of games that get BGG users really excited:
